Lone Caledonian

I'm not saying weir was great. Better than what we have though and whoever played with him appeared to benefit from his experience and play better.

I certainly felt a lot more confident in our defence with Weir in there. Sure he lacked pace but this was masked by his good positional sense.

But never managed it McToot. Yet Caldwell does manage it but is seemingly bullet-proof. 

Hanley reminded me so much of Lee Wilkie.... There is something there, it's just a shame it's in the form of a total bombscare....

Serbia he tried to hard at times to be clever, and with the pitch being a ploughed potato field, that was not the place for trying stuff like what he was doing (couple of times he would try control the ball, and rather than lump it up tr park he would pass it back to the keeper, which is alright on a bowling green, but not there)

Well at least he never gift-wrapped a goal with schoolboy defending like.......oh yes Caldwell.

To be fair, Caldwell has also proven to be decent at this level too.

Webster isn't nearly good enough.
Berra can't get a game for Wolves!!

I'd happily try Martin or Mulgrew and give more games to Hanley but they will all make mistakes at some point.

Fair enough but at least give them that chance to make the mistakes that Caldwell is doing. Besides as sure as eggs are eggs Caldwell is NOT one for the future which is what we are supposed to be building for now.

Sorry no but that makes no sense. How do we know that Hanley and Martin might not work or Hanley and Mulgrew or Mulgreww and Martin etc until it is tried. The point is Caldwell has been tried and been dfound out far too many times to be given more chances. Let us see what the others can do.